Popular Articles
-
New Linguaguide ebook
No popular articles found.
Popular Authors
- Ray Vetne
No popular authors found.
|
| What a child can teach a language learner |
By Subash S L |
Published
10/24/2006
|
Learning tips
| Rating:   
|
|
|
|
What a Child Can Teach a Language Learner
On our return to our German class after summer vacation our teacher asked us a question and requested that the answer to that question be given in spoken German. The question was, “What did you do last Summer?” Our teacher wanted a minimum of two complete lines for an answer. In a class of almost 25 students there were only a handful who could provide a complete and a grammatically correct answer. Too bad for a class that had undergone a training of one complete year of study!
Who was to be blamed here? The course and curriculum? The teacher? Disappointed with the response our German teacher gave us some very valuable advice that helped many of us to not only secure better marks but also learn the language better in the succeeding months of the course.
My German teacher told us that if he had put a child of 4 or 5 years in our class and had taught the child (only slightly differently than the rest of us) then that child would have overrun most of the students in the class in speaking German. “By now the child would have started speaking”, he exclaimed. Very true indeed! Isn’t that the way millions of children learn to speak their mother-tongue or in the case of German, the father-tongue?
The teacher then continued to explain the reason why a child is such a fast and natural learner and how we too could consciously employ the techniques used by the child, the very same techniques that the child does automatically and unconsciously.
He taught us two things. These were 1. Repetition and 2. Speaking without caring too much about making mistakes. Let us look at these two learning habits of the child in more detail.
Repetition is not only the only way a child learns to mimic sounds made by adults that look after him but also after mimicking he realizes he can get things done using those sounds of the words he has learnt. For example if he is hungry he learns to say the right word for food.
Gradually his curiosity and interest makes him add more sounds to his vocabulary. Later after he learns different words of the different kinds of foods he likes he uses them instead. Therefore to him learning words is survival and it happens out of necessity. He moves from simple sounds to words and then to simple sentences using this technique.
The other aspect of his learning is that he is neither shy nor afraid to make mistakes. In fact he makes as many mistakes as he wishes to. The wonderful advantage here is that whenever the child makes a mistake he is corrected and he learns to use the new word right. So the more mistakes he makes the more he is corrected and the more he learns. The child neither has ego or worry from embarrassment or humiliation to shy away from making mistakes.
These are traits that nature has ordained for his survival. In fact in many cases where parents complain that their child is slow in learning or speaking it is the parents who are failing. Studies have shown that these parents have spent very little time in speaking to their children and thereby depriving their children the invaluable art of making their children speak or repeat and most importantly not giving them a chance of being corrected.
How can an adult learn like a child?
Now let us look at why adults who are learning a foreign language fail to use the techniques the child does. An adult’s primary problem is his or her ego that stops them from making mistakes. Feeling embarrassed in front of other grown-ups they fail to use the two most important techniques of both speaking (repetition) and making mistakes.
Speaking has another effect on the brain and the subconscious. To illustrate here is a small experiment. Take a book, a TV guide or an address book and try to remember a few events such as the shows and timings of a day’s events or an address by just reading it mentally. Make sure you don’t speak out orally the contents you are reading. Now close the books and try and write down what you have read in a piece of paper. Done? Now open the books again and read another set of similar contents as you read before. This time make sure you audibly speak out the contents as you read them. Close the books once again and as before write down what you have just read in another piece of paper. Compare the two writings you just did. Didn’t the second writing feel easier and have more correct and comprehensive contents than what you wrote in the first piece of paper?
This is a simple exercise demonstrating the power of the spoken word on the mind when it comes to retention and recall. We do this several times in a day like remembering an important errand, remembering a name when someone is introduced to us etc. but when it comes to learning a language many of us force ourselves to speak and read less and are not being benefited from the power of this simple yet very useful habit.
So the important advice: Read aloud and try to orally speak as much as possible the language you are learning. It will be a good practice at this juncture to make sure you pronounce the syllables, sounds and words as accurately as possible in the original language.
The second and more important habit of the child, and beneficial to all of us ,is to make as many mistakes as possible and be corrected. For this a change in attitude is what can be considered most essential. Learning to understand that others in the class are also learners like you and I and that making mistakes will help even other students, will help create a paradigm shift, most essential for language learning.
A couple of students who took this advice to heart eventually eclipsed even the top students when it came to spoken-German. That brings us to the second and most important lesson that the child can teach us: Do not worry about making mistakes and do it without inhibition.
These are two things that children can teach us as language learners. There are other things to learn as well and these will be dealt in articles to be published soon in the future.
|
Comments
-
Comment #1
(Posted by tater03)
Rating
    
I find what your teacher said to be so true. I have a preschooler and I can see just by watching Dora how much he has learned of the Spanish language and retained. He knows how to count higher in Spainish than I do. I found this article very informative.
-
Comment #2
(Posted by starlily)
Rating
    
I have observed that there is a big difference between immersing a child into a new language, and teaching. If a child is moved into a new language environment, it is picked up effortlessly, whereas if there is only a classroom situation where there is some inhibition on the learner's part, not so effortless... That's where I think new media (such as Dora for kids) and other interactive software will be an asset, if you are unable to move to Spain for example ;) Adults need to find situations for themselves where they are able to practice their new language, other than a classroom setting... I think that is the practical application of your advice in this article: Alot of practice without inhibition. Good article!
-
Comment #3
(Posted by tater03)
Rating
    
I have found that a lot of the toys marketed now also include the spanish language with the english language. It would be kind of neat to see them do something like this for other languages. My kids love that they are learning another language and you are right it is almost effortlessly to them because they are doing it while playing.
-
Comment #4
(Posted by FourBear)
Rating
    
I think this article provides wonderful advice, but it is important to remember that it is extremely difficult (if not impossible) for an adult to match the language learning curve a child has. Studies have shown that it is easiest to learn (and not simply memorize the conventions of) a language before puberty.
-
Comment #5
(Posted by LyricB)
Rating
    
My daughter who is almost three picks up some Spanish from the toys we have, but I have no grand visions of her becoming fluent from them by any means.
-
Comment #6
(Posted by starlily)
Rating
    
lol... no, I don't forsee my child becoming fluent on Dora either...the other thing is, that children can forget 2nd languages as quickly as they have learned them, if they don't continue to use them. So I think that's why the advice, to find practical applications, is the only way to go...
-
Comment #7
(Posted by lyricb)
Rating
    
You're so right, starlily. I'm continually amazed by the parents who plop their kids down to watch a video and think the kids will become fluent forever.
-
Comment #8
(Posted by tater03)
Rating
    
I was in no way thinking that they would become fluent in a language. I just find that they retain it and learn it faster they I do as an adult. And they are touching on a language while have fun doing it.
-
Comment #9
(Posted by starlily)
Rating
    
I realize that... and totally agree with you that I appreciate that our children have these kinds of educational tools at their fingertips...although we're not depending on them alone to teach our children, they definitely provide practical learning opportunities...
-
Comment #10
(Posted by tater03)
Rating
    
I know my four year old in preschool was learning sign language and how to count to fifteen in Spanish. I thought that was pretty good. I was never taught that in school.
-
Comment #11
(Posted by FourBear)
Rating
    
When I was in elementary school, my gym teacher would count in Spanish to get us to sit into a circle. It was almost like a song, so we all knew how to count to ten pretty quickly. I also remember Sesame Street teaching me Spanish phrases when I was younger...like "hace calor." I didn't know what it meant then, but when I learned Spanish later on I remembered the phrase and finally understood!
-
Comment #12
(Posted by tater03)
Rating
    
Now that you mention it I remember Seseame Street having some Spanish on a few of the programs. I don't know about recently though my boys never really got into watching it for some reason.
-
Comment #13
(Posted by Paula62)
Rating
    
I belong to a public speaking group (toastmasters) and we have had quite a few non-native english speakers join. I am always so in awe of them, being willing to give speeches in front of lots of people in a tongue they are still learning. But those are the folks who learn the fastest, and I can literally watch the rapid imporvment of their english.
-
Comment #14
(Posted by lyricb)
Rating
    
Sesame Street does do a Spanish letter of the day, and sometimes they do sign language too. It's pretty cool.
-
Comment #15
(Posted by mtatum4496)
Rating
    
My nieces were very young when their father was stationed in Germany. The two girls had a much easier time learning the language, for the very reasons cited in this article. They were happy to repeat phrases and get comfortable with them, and they were not deterred or frightened of making mistakes as they learned.
-
Comment #16
(Posted by felice206)
Rating
    
I find it quite true as well. My son learns so much better watching dora, or using some of the new products out there. Of course I've heard several times that children have great minds and retention for languages until a certain age that is
-
Comment #17
(Posted by tater03)
Rating
    
You know after reading this and all the above comments I wonder why they don't make learning another language something that you would learn in elementary schools? I guess maybe it could be the fact that they are still basically learning the English language? But it just seems such a shame that they can learn a language so easily at a younger age but that it is not taught. I am seriously thinking about looking into maybe doing a home type studying of a language for my sons. Nothing to hard just the basics. I don't know it is something to think about that I just never really thought of until I ran across this article.
-
Comment #18
(Posted by mtatum4496)
Rating
    
I think you are right. We in the United States made a big mistake when we stopped including Latin as part of a basic educational curriculum. I would like to see us get back to teaching at least the rudiments of a language other than English in our elementary schools.
-
Comment #19
(Posted by felice206)
Rating
    
It is a shame they do not teach latin in schools any longer. I homeschool and Latin is part of our day. I find it a great help in teaching grammar, and now that we've started french as well.
-
Comment #20
(Posted by Lyricb)
Rating
    
I try to teach my daughter some stuff in other languages, and she remembers them, but I don't know enough to help her become fluent by any means.
-
Comment #21
(Posted by Paula62)
Rating
    
I very much wanted my daughter to leanr Spanish early, but even here in Texas I found very few course for elementary students. I even put her in a bilingual class at school, but they really don't teach Spanish, just use it to keep the Spanish speakers up on the subjects. She has great pronunciation, but wasn't learning anything other than basic basics. So now I am teaching her at home using curriculum I found on the internet. I think it's shameful we don't teach our kids another language when they can best learn it.
-
Comment #22
(Posted by starlily)
Rating
    
felice206, do you mind if I ask you what language curriculum you are using with your children to learn latin and french? I also homelearn, and we have access to the Rosetta Stone language program...
-
Comment #23
(Posted by tater03)
Rating
    
I would also be interested in what you are using to teach your child another language? Thank you.
-
Comment #24
(Posted by mtatum4496)
Rating
    
I would be interested in knowing more about those home school resources as well. Perhaps they would be helpful for me, along with helping my son learn Spanish.
-
Comment #25
(Posted by felice206)
Rating
    
Sure, I use a combination of powerglide and memoria press http://www.memoriapress.com/index.html for latin - both can usually be found quite easily on ebay for much cheaper.
For french powerglide or rosetta stone. It really depends on the child however. while my son loves the powerglide system it has been bashed by some.
Another great program that people have liked for both a variety of languages is pimsleur. I've used them for learning greek and love their system they dissect the word which makes it a lot easier to remember/learn
-
Comment #26
(Posted by emmy_b)
Rating
    
What a great article. I think a lot of adults over-think languages as in they analyse the reasons behind rules and exceptions of languages, children have a natural instinct to learn languages I think as they simplify the rules behind them...I found learning Italian later in life a lot harder than learning French when I was a kid, did anyone else feel like this?
-
Comment #27
(Posted by tater03)
Rating
    
Thank you felice. I am definently interested in this. I will have to check out these sites and programs. Thanks again.
-
Comment #28
(Posted by starlily)
Rating
    
Thanks for the info felice! I noticed that Rosetta Stone offers latin as well...wonder if that would be worth our time...I've heard good things about powerglide as well. Thanks for reminding me!
-
Comment #29
(Posted by felice206)
Rating
    
I've not tried Rosetta Latin, however I've heard it's not as great...it is on par with typical Rosetta Stone - so if Rosetta works for you it might be okay :)
-
Comment #30
(Posted by emmy_b)
Rating
    
Think I'll be checking these out too felice to help my nephews start to learn a new language - some great advice there, thanks.
-
Comment #31
(Posted by Starlily)
Rating
    
Felice, did you start latin with your children before you started the other languages? If so, do you think it made it easier for them? Would learning say, latin in conjunction with spanish or french be overload for children do you think?
-
Comment #32
(Posted by felice206)
Rating
    
I started off with latin, I think starting latin with young children is the best way to go as a first language. Really depends on if the child is ready. I started with 2 years of Latin before we moved on to french. At this point he's got a good foundation so he doesn't mind learning 2 languages. :)
-
Comment #33
(Posted by sweet_mayhem)
Rating
    
this is a very informative article. i did encounter before some of the points mentioned in your article, but some are new to me. i learned back in college that the adoption of a NEW language(i'm not talking here of the mother tongue) for adults and children are different. linguists say that learning ANOTHER language is much easier taught to a child than to an adult. i can't remember the term that they have for it, but linguists claim that there is a certain age which after that, people would find it harder to adopt a new language. i'm not sure if it's the age of saturation, i couldn't remember.
for adults, the process of adopting a new language is called learning, while for children it is acquisition. language learning is a process wherein we adults are aware that we are being taught; we feel the stress or pressure that the lessons come with. we seem to have that other voice inside us that says, "i have to learn this. i'm learning another language." but for a child, since there's none yet of the ego which adults have, and she may not realize that she's actually being taught a new thing, she doesn't feel the pressure of having to adopt a new language; she subconsciously gets it, therefore she doesn't learn the language, she acquires it meaning the adoption becomes very natural.
-
Comment #34
(Posted by sweet_mayhem)
Rating
    
by the way, felice, thanks for that link. i should definitely check it out soon. i am also looking into having other online tutorial sources to learn a new language.
-
Comment #35
(Posted by Starlily)
Rating
    
You made a good point about language acquisition sweet mayhem. Thanks for all the info Felice! I am really considering doing a year of latin with the kids before starting another language...
-
Comment #36
(Posted by tater03)
Rating
    
I agree with you on that little voice and the stress we feel as adults because we know that we are learning. I just wish I could stop all that stress and revert to the way a child learns.
-
Comment #37
(Posted by riskey58)
Rating
    
I agree with the article.I have a grandson that has learned to count in Spanish. He is only in pre school and picked up on it very quickly.
-
Comment #38
(Posted by riskey58)
Rating
    
I do believe kids learn a lot easier.and by what they see on tv. I know my grandson has learned Spanish from watching Dora. I was really surprised what all he had learned.
-
Comment #39
(Posted by reviewer)
Rating
    
How true it is that our embarassment holds us back. It's hard to practice when you're self-conscious.
-
Comment #40
(Posted by tater03)
Rating
    
That is alot of my problem. I am afraid of making a mistake and getting laughed at. Which has actually happened already but I keep trying.
-
Comment #41
(Posted by riskey58)
Rating
    
I never thought of that before ,but it is true. A child really does not really worry about making a mistake,and when they do they are corrected,and move on from there.I think by not being afraid of making a mistake makes it easier.If we could do that as an adult it would be great.
Submit Comment
 Subscribe to the LinguaGuide email-newsletter
Empower your language learning skills with our free LinguaGuide email newsletter:
- Exclusive free articles for subscribers only
- Advice about the best language resources
- Language learning tips audios and videos
Directory of language resources
Arabic, Chinese,
Dutch, Finnish,
French, German, Greek,
Gujarati, Hebrew,
Hindi, Indonesian,
Italian, Japanese,
Korean, Latin, Polish,
Portuguese, Russian,
Spanish, Urdu
|