Popular Articles
-
New Linguaguide ebook
No popular articles found.
Popular Authors
- Ray Vetne
No popular authors found.
|
| Don't translate when you read |
By Ray Vetne |
Published
10/24/2006
|
Learning tips
| Rating:   
|
|
|
|
Don't translate when you read
Memorize words by connecting them to things, not to their corresponding word in your mother tongue. And when you read you should force yourself to understand and get a mental picture of the sentences in the foreign language directly, and not translate them into your own language first.
A normal mistake many do when they are about to learn a language is to in their minds translate the foreign language into their mother tongue. When they work on vocabulary they connect - consciously or not - the foreign word to a corresponding word in their own langauge. And when they read foreign language texts they stop after each sentence and translate it before trying to get at the meaning.
But this is not a very effective way of learning. The more you manage to "think" in the foreign language, without having to take the detour your own mother tongue, the quicker you will acquire the new language.
So when you work on new words and phrases, the secret is to try to connect it to a mental picture of what it means or represents. If you like using flash cards, make a drawing of what the word represents instead of writing the equivalent in your old language.
This will speed up your language learning. It will also make your understanding of your new language more accurate. Words and phrases in one langauge never corresponds on a one-to-one basis with words in another language. Each language "divides up the world" in words and phrases differently. When you take detours to your mother tongue, you will never fully understand and master the other language.
|
Comments
-
Comment #1
(Posted by FourBear)
Rating
    
I can't tell you how many times I've been told not to translate while reading...and it really is true! The meanings of some words just can't be translated between languages, and I find it is best to remember them in their own context (that is, the context of the language I'm learning, and not English).
-
Comment #2
(Posted by tater03)
Rating
    
You are so correct on the trying to translate the word into your mother tongue. This is something that I really have to concentrate on when I am trying to read in a foreign language. I just hope it gets easier as I learn more.
-
Comment #3
(Posted by LyricB)
Rating
    
What a great point. I knew I had finally started to understand Spanish really well when a friend asked me what a certain word meant and I couldn't literally translate it.
-
Comment #4
(Posted by starlily)
Rating
    
This article was very insightful. I really liked your phrase about language 'dividing up the world' differently in words and phrases. Very descriptive, and true...
-
Comment #5
(Posted by FourBear)
Rating
    
You brought up a great point, LyricB. People often ask me what a word means in English; I know what it means, but I can't provide a definition. Now I find that the same thing is happening with the languages I'm learning, so I guess it's a good sign!
-
Comment #6
(Posted by Paula62)
Rating
    
Oh, this is good advice. I never knew how to describe it, but I kind of discovered this myself when I was learning Spanish and non-spanish speaking friends would ask me to translate a tv show or something. I'd have to listen to a whole bit before I could tell them what was going on. Then I could tell them, but not a word for word translation. They tended to think that meant I didn't knwo Spanish very well. Hah, the laugh's on them, now.
-
Comment #7
(Posted by lyricb)
Rating
    
I'm always amazed by the folks who work as professional translators, such as for court and such. I just don't think my brain works that way.
-
Comment #8
(Posted by tater03)
Rating
    
I have tried doing that while watching a Spanish tv stations. But they seem to talk so fast that I just get lost.
-
Comment #9
(Posted by mtatum4496)
Rating
    
I've never tried this approach, but it sounds like a great way to learn another language. So much of the problem when translating from one language to another, there may be more than one "right" choice that will be defined by context. Visualization of the idea in context rather than a word for word attempt at translation strikes me as a good way to overcome that obstacle.
-
Comment #10
(Posted by Paula62)
Rating
    
definitely. I like the tv (or newspapers) because you really can't translate bit by bit, and wathcing tv broke me of the habit of thinking in english. I have trouble with radio, though, since you can't see the speakers.
-
Comment #11
(Posted by starlily)
Rating
    
I was going to ask for suggestions how NOT to translate word for word, then you reminded me of watching TV as a language tool...Thanks everyone! I have to admit though, when I'm reading I do tend to translate and it makes it rather tedious, maybe if I could just 'envision' paragraphs or chapters, it would be easier...
-
Comment #12
(Posted by Louisa)
Rating
    
What a good point. When I am speaking to someone in my 'new' foreign language by the time I have finished the person has fallen asleep! first I try to think of the words I am trying to say, then I try to think of the tense I need to speak in, then I translate it into my mother tongue to make sure it's right (it never is):-( and then eventually I actually get to speak in my 'new'foreign language! I am going to try the method in this article .... Please work :-)
-
Comment #13
(Posted by mtatum4496)
Rating
    
I was mentioning this article to a friend of mine last night, who spends part of the year in Turkey. He made a similar observation about the use of television as a way of helping him to learn to think in a way other than English.
-
Comment #14
(Posted by felice206)
Rating
    
I've heard this before, and really do try to impliment it while learning languages, it's quite a good tip. Great article especially for those new to learning
-
Comment #15
(Posted by LyricB)
Rating
    
mtatum, good luck to your friend who spends itme in Turkey. Turkish is a pretty difficult language to learn, especially for someone who starts out with English.
-
Comment #16
(Posted by FourBear)
Rating
    
I think television can help you get a language "into your head," so to speak. I also find movies helpful, but I make sure to turn off the English subtitles so I don't become reliant on their (often different) translation.
-
Comment #17
(Posted by Paula62)
Rating
    
Anyone remember the movie "Splash" with Tom Hanks and Darryl Hannah? She learned English from the TV, and if it worked for her, It could work for anyone!
-
Comment #18
(Posted by papia)
Rating
    
Firstly you should start to write as you would speak. It goes a long way to help keep the words you know in your head.
Secondly find a word in the morning... look it up in the dictionary and use it all that day. If you are feeling ambitious pick 2 words.
-
Comment #19
(Posted by papia)
Rating
    
Repetition is a key element of language learning - songs and poetry enable you to learn structures and vocabulary without realising it
-
Comment #20
(Posted by mtatum4496)
Rating
    
I had forgotten about the movie Splash. Sure enough, she learned the language by watching television and relating what she heard to what she saw. Makes perfect sense when you think about it.
-
Comment #21
(Posted by an unknown user)
Rating
    
That is a very good tip Papia. Never thought of picking one word and use it during the course of your day. Makes a lot of sense when you think about it. Thanks.
-
Comment #22
(Posted by Paula62)
Rating
    
So does anyone know of foreign language page-a-day calendars? You know the type, where you get a new cartoon, quote, inspirational message or vocabulary word very day? Maybe we should all pool our money and create some for sale!
-
Comment #23
(Posted by starlily)
Rating
    
That's a great entreprenureal idea Paula62! Start a foreign language inspirational daily email campaign... Sign me up! :)
Maybe we have some artists who could do background mural type stuff???
-
Comment #24
(Posted by emmy_b)
Rating
    
Loving the daily calendar idea - think they would be fab!! Would give you a great insight into helping you increase your foreign vocab!
-
Comment #25
(Posted by tater03)
Rating
    
That is an awesome idea about the calender. I wonder if they already make them. I would definently look into that. And if now I say go with it. Very useful and a great idea actually.
-
Comment #26
(Posted by felice206)
Rating
    
I agree the calander idea sounds really great. I'm going to have to give it a try sometime, shame they don't have more on the market could be quite beneficial!
-
Comment #27
(Posted by Paula62)
Rating
    
alright, then, so who here speaks a langugae well enough to create the days?!?! We might be the blind leading the blind. Do you think we'd get in trouble if we sold a calendar with poor grammar? lol
-
Comment #28
(Posted by tater03)
Rating
    
I don't know if we would actually get in trouble but it would be very embarrising. I can honestly say that I don't know another language enough yet. But I do think this is a very unique idea.
-
Comment #29
(Posted by FourBear)
Rating
    
I for one would buy a calendar if it existed! Nobody has seen them anywhere? I find that very surprising, especially since it could be so helpful.
-
Comment #30
(Posted by Starlily)
Rating
    
They do exist...I found some at amazon as well as calendars.com...not a wide selection, but I saw one in latin! as well as french, spanish & italian...
-
Comment #31
(Posted by an unknown user)
Rating
    
Thank you, I will have to check out Amazon. Well there goes our next big invention. I thought we were all on to something.
-
Comment #32
(Posted by emmy_b)
Rating
    
Lol Paula! I'm going to have a look at Amazon for these now - think the Spanish one might be a good Christmas gift for a friend who's learning the language!
-
Comment #33
(Posted by FourBear)
Rating
    
I might pick up one of the Spanish ones myself! And maybe a Japanese one for my boyfriend too...he's trying to convince me to learn it, maybe that will help both of us lol.
-
Comment #34
(Posted by felice206)
Rating
    
I've just picked up one in latin and one in German just to see how helpful they will really be. Sounds interesting just a shame there's not more of a variety
-
Comment #35
(Posted by riskey58)
Rating
    
I agree with you I think by picking one word and using and repeating it all day would be very helpful to me. Thanks
-
Comment #36
(Posted by riskey58)
Rating
    
I am new at learning a new language. I am older and it is not easy for me.I am going to try the idea of television.I have tried some of the ideas and they have helped. I can use help I can get.Thamk you.
-
Comment #37
(Posted by tater03)
Rating
    
I will have to check out Amazon. I have a gift certificat that I have been saving maybe I will use it for one of these to help learn Spanish. Riskey, just to let you know you are never to old to learn. Good luck to you if you decide to learn a language.
-
Comment #38
(Posted by reviewer)
Rating
    
When you have to translate it, you're not going to be successful. You need to really parse the language as you do your native tongue.
-
Comment #39
(Posted by Miley Thu)
Rating
    
Hi, I am now learning English and I feel so bad when I don't understand what words say. Would you please give me some advice about it? because I now need to learn English to go into college.Besides that, I am living in Vietnam where is not use English very much.
-
Comment #40
(Posted by george)
Rating
    
yes, very true but hard to do..
Submit Comment
 Subscribe to the LinguaGuide email-newsletter
Empower your language learning skills with our free LinguaGuide email newsletter:
- Exclusive free articles for subscribers only
- Advice about the best language resources
- Language learning tips audios and videos
Directory of language resources
Arabic, Chinese,
Dutch, Finnish,
French, German, Greek,
Gujarati, Hebrew,
Hindi, Indonesian,
Italian, Japanese,
Korean, Latin, Polish,
Portuguese, Russian,
Spanish, Urdu
|